Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They should all receive the same sentence as someone they arrested for making and selling crack cocaine would.



Indeed. Police usually get fired (w/ or w/o benefits). Or put on paid leave.

I think police should be held to a higher standard than the public: their training and their power (monopoly on violence) warrants that.

Something else: "provocation" is usually forbidden to law enforcement.

I think law enforcement needs provocation in order to catch certain bad behaviors. But certainly not for a victimless crime like dealing dope.

Where I think provocation is needed as a law enforcement tool: sexual harassment in the streets (like cat calling) and govt corruption.


No. What they did is worse. They abused their power to do the crime and evade prosecution. That's a much worse crime. It's a double standard. It undermines the entire authority system. It doesn't just harm the people they are selling crack to, it undermines the entire police system. Even a "single isolated incident" of authority abuse undermines the entire authority system.

Authorities aren't equal in the eyes of the law. They are held to a higher standard. Do I have to quote fucking Spiderman (Uncle Ben Parker)?: With great power comes great responsibility.

They should be charged with manufacturing schedule I drugs, selling schedule I drugs, AND conspiracy to defraud the {federal government,state of Florida,people of Florida,police}, and a bunch of other crimes. I would go so far as to say that such acts are those of treason. They acted in a way to undermine the trust of the American people, to undermine the justice system, to undermine the government that they are representing. It is unquestionable that they have caused a betrayal of trust.

I think this is a problem that we let slide due to apathy. But that's why I'm so pissed about this kind of stuff. It's because treason can build slowly, and even be explained away with "best intentions." But it is this slow slide that sows distrust to the institutions we have. It gives legitimate reason to be distrustful of these systems. And without going after bad actors or without holding them to a higher standard, this too undermines the entire system. I don't think you have to be draconian, but I do mean that if you get charged for selling drugs (as one charge of possibly many) you should be receive higher punishment than any non-authority person in a similar setting.


No shit. You should reconsider the context and implications.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: