Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm gonna be honest, this is much closer to the future that humanity deserves than the AI utopia many of you were dreaming of. Look at the entirety of human history and all the evil things people have done, and look at your own consumption of factory-farmed meat/dairy/eggs. Look at how few people donate kidneys (less than 0.1% in USA, and even lower in countries like Japan). And of course people would rather spend their 1st-world disposable income on enshitified creature-comforts than donate it; about $3500 is enough to save a kid's life from malaria, or go on a family vacation to Disney World.

People will say "I'd be a better person if only I were rich!", but predictably, the number of rich people willing to do those things is almost a rounding error.



>> I'm gonna be honest, this is much closer to the future that humanity deserves than the AI utopia many of you were dreaming of.

My diverse opinion: "this is much closer to the future that humanity deserves, the AI and surveillance dystopia we have been so intent on getting."


Children aren't dying of malaria due to lack of funds. They're dying due to terrible governments in those places. Unless you're advocating for regime change and colonization, no amount of money is going to fix that.

The data are unequivocal that liberal democracy, civil rights, and economic freedom lift people out of poverty, but this message is toxic in many parts of the world, and thus many countries live in unnecessary poverty, dependent upon donations from rich countries that follow the straightforwards, simple advice to be well off.


You can donate $3.5k to a relevant charity and save a kid's life.

Debating how much better things would be with better governments doesn't change that.


There's a moral calculus where you have to determine if the money is really going there and if any of the money is instead supporting a despotic regime. I don't disagree. I do donate to missions where I know the individuals personally.


Get off your high horse. Humanity has been like this since the beginning and we’ve made it quite far. Have some humility and entertain the possibility that you’re wrong.


"Humanity has been like this since the beginning and we’ve made it quite far." Agreed, we've made it all the way to the precipice of nuclear annihilation by Putin, Trump, Netanyahu, or Xi. Kim could probably get it started too.

"entertain the possibility that you’re wrong" I would absolutely love for the world to prove me wrong.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: