Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I would expect a botanist to know that a tomato is technically a berry, just like I would expect an economist to know that inflation is technically defined as an increase in the money supply.

Everyday people can use whatever definition they want. That doesn't mean economists, the Fed, etc should say "inflation" when they mean "price of goods".



Inflation is technically defined as an increase in the price level. You'll find the term defined in this way in every single economics textbook.


Entry level textbooks. It's one of those things they intentionally teach wrong to first year students in an attempt to "simplify"


Do you have a source? I've only ever seen it defined the traditional way. Besides, you can increase the money supply and not get inflation (defined the usual way). Inflation happens when the money supply increases more than the economy needs.


Inflation happens when money supply increases more than the value of the goods that you can purchase with that money supply. It isn't about needs, but things that can be bought, especially those with limited supplies like housing.


So if money supply stayed the same but a crisis reduced the supply of goods, while demand increased, then those raising prices are ... not inflation?


Say Price = Money supply / value of goods

If price goes up then inflation, if price goes down then deflation. If value of good goes down and money supply stays the same, inflation.


No, it's not an attempt to simplify. Advanced textbooks define it in the same way.


That definition depends on where you look, and when the definition was written. Between the roman empire and the mid 1900s inflation always referred to an increase in the money supply.


No, it didn't.


Bro, it's 2024.


The tomato price is too damn high!

Get it yet?


This exchange is like a microcosm of the educated elite trying to talk to ordinary people.


This comment made my day.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: