Maybe there is a context problem here from people not familiar with business exp...

gopher_space · 2024-10-17T22:12:17 1729203137

> Every program of this nature that I have had was clear that they arent giving you money, but offering to pay for a specific thing. There are clear rules for what they are willing to pay for and when.

The point of the program is to keep the kids at work longer than they'd normally stay. If you understand that and are working late, why would you not pocket the money?

s1artibartfast · 2024-10-17T22:59:36 1729205976

I don't understand the question. They have a food program for people who stay late. They don't have a cash or toothpaste program for people to stay late. It seems very clear to me.

My work has a free cab home program. That doesn't mean I can skip the cab and wander the halls taking staplers, or use my business travel card for beer.

I might argue that "hey, these things are equal value" but it doesn't matter. It wasn't what was offered.

gopher_space · 2024-10-18T21:07:22 1729285642

Once again, the point of having the program is to get people to stay later. For $25.

There's no scenario where paying attention to this money helps more than having people put in more hours at work, so what's the goal of this exercise?

withinboredom · 2024-10-17T21:24:04 1729200244

Possibly also cultural. For example, once you tell me you are giving me money, you don't have the right to tell me how to spend it.

s1artibartfast · 2024-10-17T21:49:53 1729201793

I would agree with that statement, I just dont think it describes this situation. It was never the employees money. It was permission to spend company money on food.

Giving an employee keys to the safe is not the same as giving them the contents.

withinboredom · 2024-10-18T09:11:03 1729242663

Depends on how it was worded and/or explained to the employee. Was it: "if you stay late, the company gives you an extra 25 bucks so you can eat dinner at work" or "if you stay late, you are given a 25 bucks stipend that can only be used for food"?

The former sounds like extra money that I can do whatever I want with, while the latter is much more explicit.