Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You could perhaps assume idealism in 2020. Four years later it is clear that DEI is used as a wedge to displace those you do not like and replace them with unskilled believers.



From your comment, I'm guessing you're talking about the first consequence of DEI policies?

- Using candidates' loud belief in DEI as a litmus test, even if the candidate themselves has no diverse characteristics

- Hiring diverse candidates


DEI is hardly about unskilled alternatives.

It’s only about getting people to the table who are equally qualified and capable and overlooked and under represented.

Often to the chagrin of most people who are lamenting on it changing.


Please don't take this personally, or as an attack on you. But having seen DEI first-hand, and the "equally qualified" people it has actively displaced and disenfranchised, I'd have to say that this view avoids the ugly reality on the ground wrt DEI. There is an entire country currently affected by it's poor implementation, and it's failure is just seen as more reason for efforts to be doubled and for more-extreme quotas to be put in place.


There's nothing personal to take. So you shouldn't take it personally.

Perhaps, instead we can think about how could it be taken it professionally..

There's equal or better qualified candidates for every position that don't make it to the table because of existing gatekeeping.

That would likely have the effect of helping borderline candidates who can fail upwards, maybe do that a little less... or level up.

What's curious is the presumption that one persons experience or interpretation (yours) doesn't mean a better perspective, experience can't exist.

Is it possible you might not be the only one experiencing DEI?

Gatekeeping has been a thing that's existed for a very, very, very long time. Often to the benefit of many of the people complaining about new kinds of space-making that affect gatekeeping that they didn't realize benefitted them.

This current wave of DEI is definitely early. It's not perfect. Neither was the gatekeeping that preceded it.

Other things that were early got a lot more leeway and understanding. But it can shows what some folks want to see happen (or not happen) one way or the other.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: