Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yeah; my doctor recommends neilmed sinus rinse, in the little squirt bottle and powder packet form factor. I keep a gallon of distilled water in the bathroom. Problem solved. (Avoid the maximum strength formulation unless you want to use osmotic pressure to reduce swelling — ouch!)

If you go for the carbonated mist spray stuff, note that you get a lot less volume of water per dose, so it’s a bit less reliable (but much more convenient since you don’t need to worry about sterilizing anything).

Regarding the article: Unless you’re using this when completely symptom free (or have some condition where your sinuses are chronically dry), there’s probably already more crap in your sinuses than you need. I’m skeptical of this new technology.



That's it exactly for me. Squirt bottle seems more effective than Neti pot, just because there's some force in the water.

You DO need the powder, though; otherwise the water burns like hell.


On the other hand, don't think you can get away without the salt packet either. I think that's worse than too much salt.


Any information about nettie pot vs the squirt bottle you use?


The pressure of a squirt bottle can make it go all up in the sinuses behind your eyes which is really painful when all you prob want is for it to take the short passage to the other nostril. Happened to me the last time I used it and it hurt for an hour, granted I'm always too lazy to dissolve the salt which apparently makes it hurt less.

I never had that problem with a neti pot since gravity can't apply as much pressure. So you're forced to be patient when it's especially blocked up.


Gravity vs. active pressure.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: