Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Fwiw wal-e has been deprecated for a while - I’m a big fan of pgbackrest



Edited to wal-g, since that is what I'm using now; I forgot I had to switch over, but indeed I did.

Did you jump straight to pgbackrest or compare it to wal-g? I didn't compare em at all, so I have no clue if I'm missing out on something nice or important there


I wonder if we should ditch pgbackrest now that PostgreSQL 17 has the new backup thing.


I think the next few years it will not be dead, there are a lot of instances who can not easily be ported to 17. But yeah, i also read about that new feature a few days ago.


Yeah i can also recommend, i even use it to push incremental backups to ssh (nas is to old to install minio), other servers use s3.

I have it included in timescale image.. so full restore is: spinning up a temporary image, restore, restart compose. So do i with with incremental. File based restore is pretty fast.

For me its a setup and forget thing.

For etc i use gitkeep sometimes (machines who are also configured by devs itself), to have an audit like thing, with a central gitea repo in the project cluster to see changes.

For files i use restic to ssh, also s3 possible. i like the deduplication they do.

And otherwise i use proxmox, doing snapshots on HDDs at night, and at the day i move those sliwly to external nas again, keeping the last few snaps on ssd,hdd to be able to recover fast. and if the machine got dead, i have the external backups.

I also do this the same way on hetzner with my bare metals, storing an encrypted backup (restic deduped and encrypted) to external storage. Server is also proxmox with encrypted disks, so to boot up, you need to send encryption keys via secure ssh.

Also another aproach with configs is, having a clean deployment/infra config (ansible, pyinfra, terraform...), and then only restoring data, so everything is reproducable and consistent.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: