Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

FYI, this post was ranking fairly high on the front page, then it just vanished.



Users flagged it. Correctly of course.


Can you explain why it should be flagged? At least ostensibly, it seems earnest, introspective (at the site level), and of interest to the community.

(My best guess is perhaps HN doesn’t allow posts about HN. Or perhaps posts based on speculation.)


> perhaps HN doesn’t allow posts about HN

We don't disallow them, but meta is the crack of internet forums, so the bar for those to be on topic is high. The current post doesn't come close to clearing the bar.

Why? Because such perceptions are extremely common and nearly always bogus. You've fallen into the trap (<-- I don't mean to pick on you personally! it's extremely common, as I say) of arriving at an overgeneralization based on a small handful of datapoints that you happened to personally notice. The reality is that HN hosts tons of negative threads about Google. A couple minutes with HN Search is sufficient to establish this. There are also neutral threads about Google and positive threads about Google, of course—it's a big company—but the negative probably dominates.

Hypergeneralization-about-HN-based-on-tiny-set-of-datapoints-that-coalesce-into-perception-that-feels-convincing-but-in-fact-is--bogus-and-which-has-strong-inflammatory-qualities-that-fit-other-peoples-priors-perfectly-and-get-them-going is just about the most common phenomenon that exists on this site and is definitely not the basis for an on-topic submission!


I believe there's a certain degree of "reputation management" happening with HN, and it seems unfair that we're not allowed to even talk about it.

That being said, I can understand why you don't want to see the comments degenerate into people accusing each other of being shills and bots.


I'd be happy to answer whatever you want to know about how we run HN but you'll have to explain to me what "reputation management" means. It sounds gross though.


It's often talked about here on HN, sometimes goes by the name ORM:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reputation_management

You can easily hire people to manipulate websites.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: