Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Consensus is clearly 66% or 50% depending on whether you think the GB and BG combinations are the same thing in the context of the question.

But isn't it true that more boys than girls are born (because boys die younger so evolution tries to balance it out a bit)?

Does anyone know if certain fathers can only produce one sex of child? If so then having one girl would increase the chances of having another girl slightly.




Evolution doesn't try to balance anything - evolution is not a person, and it doesn't think.

There is a slight difference in the swimming speed of XX vs XY sperm, which accounts for the difference. Also I believe females have a slightly better survival ratio, the reasons are complicated, but include the fact that all fetuses start as female, and then are modified by testosterone to be male, i.e. female is the default. Plus females have XX so some genes are doubled which helps them.

It's pretty much impossible for a father to make just one or the other because of that way it's produced.

The father has XY cells, which split in half to make sperm, one half become a male sperm the other female. So sperm is always made in pairs.

There can be differences in the mother that affect one or the other differently though (PH for example, and the sperm are not the same size).


I wasn't suggesting that evolution thinks, I was suggesting that we've evolved to produce more males so that there's an optimum 50/50 balance of the number of males and females at around early adulthood. Considering some of the other things that evolution has achieved that seems like a pretty reasonable thing to suggest.

Your explanation of whether certain couples can only produce males or females was pretty interesting though, thanks.


I don't think that reason (males die younger) explains it.

Although women may live longer they lose their ability to reproduce earlier so I would expect more girls than boys.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: