Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You future employer might expect you to bring some value through your expertise that doesn't come from her LLM. If you want to insist on degrading your own employability like this, I guess it's your choice.



For the most part, businesses don't care how you deliver value, just that you do. If programmer A does a ticket in 3 days with an LLM, and programmer B takes a week to do the same ticket, but doesn't use an LLM, with programmer B choosing not to out of some notion of purity, who's more employable?


Productivity is not the only aspect of our profession that matters, and in fact it's probably not even the most important part. I'm not suggesting we get stuck or handcraft every aspect of our code, and there are multitudes of abstractions and tools that enhance productivity, including everything from frameworks to compilers.

What I'm saying is what the original comment is doing, having the LLM write all their code, will make them a less valuable employee in the long term. Participating in the act of programming makes your a better programmer. I'd rather have programmer B if they take the time to understand their code, so that when that code breaks at 4am and they get the call, they can actually fix it rather than be in a hole they dug with LLMs that they can't dig out of.


You don't need to call them at 4am, you can keep a git log of the prompts that were used to generate the code and some professional 4am debugger can sit there and use an LLM to fix it.

Probably not a practical option yet, but if we're looking at the long term that is where we are heading. Or, realistically, the even longer term where the LLM self-heals broken systems.


While a git log of prompts seems like a novel idea to me, I don't believe it would work - not because of temperature and LLMs being non-deterministic and the context window overflowing, but because at a certain level of complexity LLMs simply fail, even though they are excellent at fixing simple bugs.


Lol, yeah the prompt is definitely going to help clarify what the code actually does.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: