Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Every prediction about the future--this one, every other one ever made, and every other one that will ever be made--is implictly made under the assumption that if the prediction lies beyond the predictor's lifespan, then the predictor will not be in a position to care one whit about the veracity of the prediction when that time comes. My clarification isn't at all motivated based on what the parent commenter said (I find the construction of a skyhook approximately as likely as the construction of a space elevator, which is to say, it will "never, ever" happen), but rather as an explicit clarification of the aforementioned implicit assumption.


My trouble with this definition of never ever is that it prevents us from starting on endeavors that may take a long time--a self fulfilling prophecy.

We may never ever mitigate our climate concerns, which obfuscates that it is a choice we'll have made, not an inevitability.


What would you say to someone who claims that "never" obviously means "not before the end of this quarter, cause who could possibly care about anything beyond that"?


Why does it matter whether their caring about whether their prediction is correct, is done at the time that their prediction is about?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: