Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> And look how that worked out for them.

Worked out pretty well to be fair, their old UI actually worked perfectly on Linux via Moonlight. Moonlight was more usable than Flash on Linux which was an unstable mess.

> There are plenty of linters for C#, sure. But no-one would write a general linter in it. It was an example that came to mind because that was how Facebook first started adopting OCaml - a linter is a small standalone tool, so it's an ok place to experiment with a new technology stack.

Except ReSharper lints for other things too.

> I mean the equivalent of Bitbucket Server or GitLab, the thing you'd run to host your own source repos internally.

That was CodePlex, there's also Azure DevOps? Which does all the things BitBucket and GitLab do and probably more? It is arguably poorly named in my view, since I've heard managers confuse "DevOps" and "Azure DevOps" by using the term interchangeably.




> Except ReSharper lints for other things too.

Up to a point - it lints the things you might need in a C# application. But it's very much a tool for the MS/Windows/C# vertical - even using it in Rider isn't really their focus. If JetBrains was building the linter they used for all IDEA-family IDEs in C#, that would be interesting.

> Azure DevOps

Right, that's the kind of thing I'm talking about. Is anyone using that who's not already bought into MS/Windows/C#, is that a market they sell to at all? Can you even run it on anything other than Windows? It sounds like not, which rather proves the point.

"microsoft didn't really care much about building a community or getting it to work natively in other OSes/toolchains" still rings true IMO. C# has some great stuff if you're fully onboard with the MS stack, but they've taken at most baby steps towards fitting into other environments. (If anything it feels like they expect the rest of the world to fit in with them - if you want to bring e.g. Postgres into your MS/Windows/C# world that's relatively well supported, but going the other direction is much less so)


Rider has the same analyzers as ReSharper, likely more (I haven't touched the latter in ages).

Moreover, the ecosystem mainly gravitates to Roslyn analyzers which run within build system and, naturally, integrate with Roslyn LSP. They work regardless of IDE or text editor you choose.

In fact, quite a lot of them come out of box, with the basic set enabled by default to prevent you from obvious mistakes, automatically fixing code to use terser syntax or avoiding footguns when using low-level APIs where applicable, and a lot more opt-in for a specific scenario or a workload.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: