Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That feels like a Maxwell's Demon kind of infinitely intelligent to me.

I recognise this might be a failure of imagination on my part, given how many times I've seen other people say "no AI can possibly do XYZ" even when an AI has already done XYZ — but based on what I see, it's extrapolating beyond what I am comfortable anticipating.

The character of The Doctor can be excused here, not only for being fictional, but also for having a time machine and knowing how the universe is supposed to unfold.




We're well into Maxwell's Demon thought experiment-grade territory here. An ASI that dooms the human race is absolutely the same sort of intellectual faffing about that Maxwell proposed in 1867 with his though experiment, though it wasn't refered to as a demon until later, by Lord Kelvin, in 1874. It wouldn't be until the early 1970's that the Unix daemon would come about.

https://www.nature.com/articles/009441c0


AI don't need to even be as smart as us to pose a threat.

Covid, HIV, ebola, cancer, these are just small genetic sequences that are optimising very hard for their own reproduction.


If your want to look at successes, corn, albeit with some modifications, and domesticated animals, have also been really successful at making sure their DNA reproduces.


Crops, pets, and livestock are symbiotic with us, they don't hurt us. The things I listed harm their host, they had to be in that category to make the point that harming us doesn't require high IQ — the harms we suffer from corn very much count as our own fault.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: