Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Or more recently, Brightline built a private high speed rail in Florida for $5 billion, spanning 170 miles. It’s hard to imagine a plausible reason this should cost 100 billion, especially given the fact they already have Amtrak rail running through California



“High speed” ended up being about 70mph. Max of 77mph in Florida.


> Max of 77mph in Florida.

Not exactly what can be found on Wikipedia. [0]

The article reads: Orlando-Cocoa: 125 mph (200 km/h)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brightline


They have made some changes to combat the negative press but still wrong.

Orlando to Miami 236 miles. Time listed on Wikipedia 210min or 3.5hrs. 236/3.5=67mph.

Many previous articles complained of slow speeds but they are listing unloaded speeds or something.

Speeds to Miami:

West palm beach 54-60mph

Boca Raton: 60mph

Fort Lauderdale: 60mph

Aventura: 67mph


> Orlando to Miami 236 miles. Time listed on Wikipedia 210min or 3.5hrs. 236/3.5=67mph.

As an average speed, that is of course correct. But that includes 6 stops along the way, as well as the time needed to enter and exit the stations before being back on high-speed tracks, and the time needed to decelerate/accelerate.

So that doesn't preclude a top speed of 125 mph on some portions of the track.

Ideally you would want a high-speed train on dedicated track, with dedicated stations, and few stops, as done in France, for example. You can choose to have train connections from stations inside city centers, as done in Germany, but than you will loose a lot of time actually getting to these stations, and consequently have a substantial lower average traveling speed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: