Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> It’s more fun to imagine these people as noble warriors against an unjust society, rather than seem them as people abusing the laws for personal gain at the expense of random victims.

Allow me to present a third option: maybe these people aren't noble warriors, they're just victims of an unjust society trying to meet their basic human need for housing. People like your friend are certainly unjustly harmed in this situation, but the people who don't even have their basic needs met are far more harmed.




If you don’t have your basic needs met there are options beyond squatting and exploiting laws surrounding it. I’m sure Spain has public services that are much better than the US if the train network is any proxy for effective governance. There’s presumably training opportunities to upskill both formal and informal. All this to say the person who is squatting is probably not someone who lacks any other option but someone who is exploiting a condition and potentially tied to organized crime to boot.


> If you don’t have your basic needs met there are options beyond squatting and exploiting laws surrounding it.

Links?

> I’m sure Spain has public services that are much better than the US if the train network is any proxy for effective governance.

Maybe you should be less sure.

> There’s presumably training opportunities to upskill both formal and informal.

Just because something can be presumed does not mean one should presume it.

> All this to say the person who is squatting is probably not someone who lacks any other option but someone who is exploiting a condition and potentially tied to organized crime to boot.

Seems like what you think is probable isn't based in much evidence.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: