Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Legally, yes, sometimes the source of the copying is in fact criminally culpable (the print shop), but usually only if they understood what was going on.

If a print shop in Los Angeles were to serve a high volume of student customers, and the print shop knew they were breaking the law by making copies of textbooks and selling them, the print shop would have a massive liability over its head. It would require proving that the print shop knew what the students were doing.




"It would require proving that the print shop knew what the students were doing"

Exactly. It would require proving. The article is arguing that it did not happen


Yes, that's what's at trial here. But in the post I replied to, I was taking issue with the insinuation that "OF COURSE that's what was happening here!" As if to imply online storage with easy download is inherently about piracy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: