Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

However, Andrew Sharp, Ben’s cohost on SharpTech was a lawyer and he also says that the judicial system is not the way to go and they should pass laws.

But you don’t have to be a lawyer to know the statements of fact are in correct as far as the technology.

They also condemned EUs ruling against Facebook where Facebook can’t even give users a choice of having an ad free experience by paying.

I have no problem paying money for stuff I want. I think that’s an honest transaction.

On Dithering, Gruber commended the EU for actually passing a simple law forcing Apple to open up NFC and the USB C mandate for iPhones instead of dragging it through some arcane legal doctrine. He didn’t necessarily agree with the law. But it was at least straightforward and honest.

But even if you aren’t a lawyer - the things that most HN users care about were not addressed at all in the lawsuit. For instance there is no mention of the App Store at all except concerning NFC, cloud gaming (that Apple has already addressed) and whatever apps are called with other embedded apps.

And no one in the Apple commentary community thinks the anti steering provision for Spotify and Kindle and Netflix etc is legitimate nor the former ban on cloud gaming.

Right now I’m listening to the Talk Show podcast with Gruber and Jason Snell (former editor in chief of Macworld) and they aren’t giving Apple a pass at all for the three items I mentioned




Excellent points.

> For instance there is no mention of the App Store

In fact the DOJ would have likely had issues doing that given Apple’s recent victory in that point against Epic (whatever you think of it).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: