Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

By "significantly heavier" it is often a difference of a few hundred pounds on a few thousand pound vehicle. A 2L engine is about 400lbs, an automatic transmission is another 220lbs, 20 gallons of gas is 120 lbs, add another 100ish pounds for a much larger cooling system. So sure, the battery is like 1,000lbs but you traded 840 pounds for 200 pounds of EV motors (assuming two of them!) so in reality you're up like 360lbs.

Combined with regenerative braking, it doesn't make that big of difference in total energy usage. A massive chunk of the energy used in an EV is aero drag which makes little difference about weight. Weight makes a bigger impact with stop and go traffic on non-regen cars as slowing down that extra mass turns more energy into heat. An object in motion wants to stay in motion and all, once you're up to speed you're using about the same energy. This is why a lot of the EV trucks have close to the same range if the bed is full or not assuming it has the cover on the bed, but towing even a small trailer becomes a massive range hit.

I get on average 3.5mi/kWh in my EV, ~1MJ/mi. A gallon of gas is like 120 MJ, an average hybrid will get like 40mpg, so 3 MJ/mi being burned. You'd need to get like 120mpg to match my average efficiency of energy usage, and my EV isn't even that incredibly efficient of an EV.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: