Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

There's a lot of the rider's bias leaking through here. "Men who seemed to be of higher social class", "Middle Class Men", complete assumptions and biases that aren't used to form any sort of conclusion. Frustrating in an otherwise enjoyable and interesting essay.



I imagined it to be similar to how some "blue collar" professions attract mostly men who openly discuss women in sexual ways with each other while at work and will cat-call a pretty woman walking by.

Likewise, a group of business men in suites are less likely to engage in this behavior. It's impossible for the unicyclist to measure people's class standing but you can get a lot of context clues by their appearance and behavior. Maybe it includes some bias, but for the purpose of logging all interesting responses I thought it was approximate enough.


Blue collar men chat up women passing by. White collar men in suits rape their subordinate women. Those nasty low class blue collar men!


> I imagined it to be similar to how some "blue collar" professions attract mostly men who openly discuss women in sexual ways with each other while at work and will cat-call a pretty woman walking by.

Bro if you're trying to count those responses by class you can't use those same responses to put them into the bins in the first place, and reproducing a classist stereotype for no reason doesn't make the point any more valid.


From his writing he sounds British, where class has a somewhat different context and from what I gather, can be inferred from speech/dress.


From his writing:

     Social and ethnic differences seemed to soften the male response, and such a softening was also noted when unicycling in Framlingham, a small Suffolk town to which I had moved from Newcastle. 
responses varied between a large hard industrial northern England city and a softer more rural and idyllic town.


I saw a comedy video recently in which the comic suggested that a man using an umbrella in Newcastle was enough to provoke comedic insults from passers by.

If the film Jaws was set in North-East England:

https://youtu.be/PLNA_57a9qE




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: