Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

As soon as we are post scarcity, we don't need capitalism any more

If you compare agriculture 1000 years ago with agriculture today, we're already in post scarcity. I suspect the game theoretic mechanisms will keep it going for awhile yet.




I don't know if we are post-scarcity. Our inputs to agriculture (lots and lots of fossil fuels) are not post-scarcity in any sense. Multiply by the scale of humanity and it's difficult to argue we're post-scarcity in agriculture. We might have more food than people to feed, but that doesn't mean if nothing changed we'd be able to sustain our level of production.


Our inputs to agriculture (lots and lots of fossil fuels) are not post-scarcity in any sense.

Yes, but our levels of productivity per-farmer would look like utter Sci-fi to a medieval peasant, if they had a notion of Sci-fi.

Also, by these standards, 1st world societies are fantasy lands, where the even the poor are fat, and have magical machines to keep food fresh, deliver music and entertainment, wash clothes and dishes. (Not all, but still.)

What we posit today as post-scarcity, will likely just move the goal posts for scarcity.


As society levels-up, the definition of scarce will continually expand as we confound wants with needs. I'm not sure how in a world of infinite wants you can "out-technology" resource demands.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: