Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

YT premium is one of the few subscriptions I find reasonable tbh. Youtube music, no ads on youtube, my conscience is clean, and I support creators.



> no ads on youtube

Really? No ads baked-in into videos by the creators? I.e. those skipped by another add-on, sponsorblock?

> and I support creators.

Are you sure about that? Why do they need to put their own ads into videos then?

By paying Netflix, Amazon Prime, or other streaming service, you surely would: Netflix and Amazon have to pay for the content. But Youtube? They get it for free.

> my conscience is clean,

But your privacy-awareness should be on alert. For YouTube premium, you have to be logged in. You can bet, that Google profiles you based on what you watch. They just don't show you the ads right on the YouTube, but surely they do elsewhere on their network.

Think of it like browser equivalent of the smart tv connected to net.


> Really? No ads baked-in into videos by the creators? I.e. those skipped by another add-on, sponsorblock?

Sponsorblock, yes.

> Are you sure about that? Why do they need to put their own ads into videos then?

For the people who use ad-blockers. Not me specifically and youtube doesn't provide a functionality to skip certain parts on paid views.

> But your privacy-awareness should be on alert. For YouTube premium, you have to be logged in. You can bet, that Google profiles you based on what you watch. They just don't show you the ads right on the YouTube, but surely they do elsewhere on their network.

I use kagi (paid), and ad-blockers for everything else.

I can live with google having access to my [poor] music taste and view history.


> and I support creators

YT cut off my favorite channels' monetization all the time. They'll never get a dime out of me.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: