Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Recipes cannot be copyrighted.



what if I prefix the recipe with a long rambling anecdote about my grandpappy’s old farm and the smell of fresh potatoes in the cellar


The recipe is still not copyrightable. The color commentary is, but anyone can just strip that out and republish the recipe in any way they see fit.


My point stands. Who owns the copyright for the data entered into this system, who owns the copyright for the 'transformed' version of it?


Can they be patented though? I was having this thought the other day and didn’t really check. I guess not, but it’s kind of ironic as a patent is basically a recipe.


Not typically. The mere combination of known ingredients does not result in a new and non-obvious invention that can be patented. A patent typically covers a unique or non-obvious process. There are exceptions, say, if there is a process that results in a foodstuff having a longer shelf life, or a novel way of reproducing a flavor (but not the recipe of the flavoring, per se). Cooking something with heat is not a unique or non-obvious process.

You could copyright the exact wording but that wouldn't protect the recipe itself and simply substituting a measurement unit may be enough to get around that. You could make it a trade secret but since the onus is on the owner to protect it and keep it confidential, that probably doesn't include publishing it or even sharing it with your AI assistant. Might involve courtside arguments about "reasonable expectations of privacy" .. I wouldn't want to test it.

It's not like there's specific wording saying that recipes cannot be patented, but if you can describe it in the traditional ingredients + preparation steps then it does not meet patentable criteria.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: