Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's almost the opposite of a Culture novel; the mainstream small-c culture is an extremely hierarchical, religious, rather technophobic, pseudo-capitalist society (the Dwellers are arguably a bit more Culture-y).

I'm not sure it's clear that Luceferous is even the villain. He's pretty unpleasant, obviously, but almost a side-issue.

The other major non-Culture sci-fi novel, Against a Dark Background, is also notably un-Culture-y.




It’s weird how Banks can casually create a villain character with such depth and richness almost as a side character and discard the character, whereas other sci fi books/movies would build everything around such a character, if they could manage to make one, which they can’t.


I'm not sure any [M] Banks books have a villain as a central character. Closest would probably be Veppers in Surface Detail (a wonderful creation, one of the most dislikable villains in any work), but even then he's arguably slightly a side-character.


That makes me think of the Ethnarch Kerian scene from Use of Weapons - which would make a brilliant cold open for a Culture movie.... <sigh>


There's no need for Culture movies.

I don't get why people think great books should be made into movies.

Some books just shouldn't.

The Culture should never be made into movies, and why would you want to, except for some sort of Hollywood reason.


I've wanted to see a movie of Consider Phlebas ever since I read the book in one sitting (literally) in May 1988... :-)

Edit: I remember it vividly as I took one day off between handing in my final year project on the CS degree I was doing and starting the final round of revision for the exams that were starting soon.

Wandered down to Bauermeister Books on the George IV bridge and picked up a copy and spent the rest of the day (until the wee small hours) reading it.


> I don't get why people think great books should be made into movies.

Because some of us suffer from aphantasia and can't just fully experience a book.


The other major non-Culture sci-fi novel ...

Feersum Endjinn would like to have a word with you


Oh, yeah, forgot about that one. I don't think it's really particularly clear where it's set at all; very little detail given about the wider world, IIRC.


Its the best one! Set on Earth, far future, millennia after most of humanity left for the stars.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: