Sickening. Podcasts are a simple RSS-based mechanism that points to sound files. The whole point of them is that you can find them "wherever you get your podcasts", no feudal lord has a monopoly over them, no company controls the distribution (despite efforts by Spotify, Audible and others to incorrectly use the word "podcast" for some of their exclusive content). YouTube Music isn't an appropriate substitute, just a way of injecting additional ads and sucking more data in.
This seems like an upstream concern with distribution, no?
Nothing in this announcement indicates YouTube Music will attempt to control distribution. YouTube might give exclusive content a try (a la Spotify), but — to your point — that won't be a "podcast" in the strict client-agnostic-syndication sense.
As long as podcast creators are publishing mp3s to RSS/Atom feeds, YouTube Music is just another podcast client (like Google Podcasts was) which you're free to avoid.
> YouTube Music is just another podcast client (like Google Podcasts was) which you're free to avoid.
My partner uses Google Podcasts because it was preinstalled. The vast majority of folks don't know that they have a choice, let alone that they should find/choose an app. Hell, that's really the only reason Apple Podcasts has any traction: it came preinstalled.
"Normal" people don't know what an RSS feed is, they don't care, and they don't want to learn. They just want to listen to podcasts.
I don't understand how this pertains to my comment. Nobody's arguing whether listeners will, as a matter of preference, avoid Google/Apple/Spotify podcast clients. Nobody makes a claim about how many people know of RSS.
It's up to the podcast producers to decide for/against distributor-exclusivity, determining whether OC has to use YouTube Music.
> The vast majority of folks don't know that they have a choice, let alone that they should find/choose an app.
That's... fine. What matters is whether they do have a choice if they go looking for one — again, that's up to podcasters, not up to Google.
The websites for podcasts often seen to hide the RSS feed/mp3 files while having giant buttons all over the place for Apple podcasts and spotify. They feed their listeners to those platforms on a platter.
Yes, but if you search for the podcast by name with your favorite podcast app, it will be found. Unless it is a fake podcast (like a Spotify exclusive).
Agreed, but I suspect that a lot of them who already use Google Podcasts won't be thrilled to have to switch to YouTube Music and may be looking around for choices when the date of cancellation gets closer.
