Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Sure. But have you tried paying for electricity here?

In France, if you look at your EDF (national electricity company) invoice, you'll see that you pay VAT (a tax) on top of other taxes.

They also levy VAT on the "Greffier"'s fees. That's a clerk at the "commerce tribunal", which is basically a part of the state administration with which you interact whenever you need any administrative changes for a company. Say, you need to declare a change of address.




Both of these things are rates set by the government. If they weren't charging VAT on the fees, they would just recalculate the base fees accordingly


Sure, but in the case of electricity, it's no different from the other poster's “just because we can fee” and “fee for processing your fee”. All these are added on top of the advertised "contract fee" and actual electricity price.

They don't advertise prices such that you can take the advertised fixed fee, add your consumption times the advertised kWh price, and have your final amount due. No, they add a "tax on energy consumption", a "contribution to the public electricity service", and a "contribution to electricity delivery". And, on all of these, they levy the VAT.

> they would just recalculate the base fees accordingly

And I think this willingly done, to give the impression that taxes are lower than they really are. Which makes the whole thing seem dishonest.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: