Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Last I checked we had registered owners for each cm of the world.

It's not very different from a world where there aren't registered owners, if you think about it.

Even in complete anarchy, in the best case scenario most people would want the world to function in a similar way, using similar mechanisms. Except that people that couldn't defend themselves or have enough social capital would be even less protected.

So perhaps you wouldn't have an official "registry", but everyone would know which parts of the territory "belongs" to whom anyway. In the worst case, it would lead to a lot more territorial conflict.

Or you could have a government enforcing equal amounts of land for every person, but this would be extremely wasteful for many reasons.

Capitalism is what allows you to globally allocate land in the most efficient way that we know of, just like any other limited resource.

> Like a game of monopoly where one player gets all the streets and all the money and the other player starts with nothing.

Capitalism allows for social / class mobility without coercion. In fact, it's the only system that directly rewards you with upwards social / class mobility in proportion to how much you are helping other humans.

> It is just more coercion, more of the same.

> More funny, if the species (in the long run) wants to survive this wild ride though space on this ball of mud coercion is the only possible answer. I'm trying to doubt it as hard as I can but wanting something to be true doesn't usually make it so.

What are you being coerced into?

Helping other people so that other people also help you getting food cheaply and conveniently so that you don't die, as well as thousands of other goods and services that even the most powerful king of a thousand years ago could not even dream of having?

You don't even have to do that, you could grow your own food and just don't go to the supermarket if you think you are up for it.

Although yes, you would need to get access to some exclusive parcel of land, just like in any alternative system. Most people would not be very happy if you go plant things in their front yard without their permission, no matter which system you live under.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: