> But that she [Greta Thunberg] is all doom and gloom instead of trying to help us progress technology
I’ve been hearing this a lot lately, that climate doomerism is somehow damaging to the cause and preventing any meaningful climate action.
I think this is a misunderstanding of what climate doomerism is. I hear people talking as if being realistic about damning nature of the damage we have done, and who is to blame for it all. And instead people believe the message is that we should just give up. If you believe the latter, I dare you to go find any source where Greta Thunberg (or any other supposed climate doomer) has said anything of that nature (hint they haven’t).
But suppose that you are right, and the message of climate doomers is actually that of giving up, now if you compare that to the decades of misdirection and outright lying that the fossil fuel industry has done to actively hinder climate action, and on top of that to actually double down on burning fossil fuels. How much damage, relative to the fossil fuel industry, have people like Greta Thunberg actually caused. Relatively speaking that damage is a drop in the ocean.
I'm not sure what could be done much better than what Greta does given her environment. I believe so far her impact on climate awareness is large net positive, and that alone - the putting the problem front and center before many people - should already help at least somewhat with mitigating it. Not to mention other, largely positive effects of her work.
I’ve been hearing this a lot lately, that climate doomerism is somehow damaging to the cause and preventing any meaningful climate action.
I think this is a misunderstanding of what climate doomerism is. I hear people talking as if being realistic about damning nature of the damage we have done, and who is to blame for it all. And instead people believe the message is that we should just give up. If you believe the latter, I dare you to go find any source where Greta Thunberg (or any other supposed climate doomer) has said anything of that nature (hint they haven’t).
But suppose that you are right, and the message of climate doomers is actually that of giving up, now if you compare that to the decades of misdirection and outright lying that the fossil fuel industry has done to actively hinder climate action, and on top of that to actually double down on burning fossil fuels. How much damage, relative to the fossil fuel industry, have people like Greta Thunberg actually caused. Relatively speaking that damage is a drop in the ocean.