Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> trash has ended up in the same landfills they were going to before.

People regularly raise this as a criticism of recycling.

It's kind of like complaining about medicine if you go to see a homeopath or a snake oil salesman.

Medicine has not "backfired", you just got tricked into doing something that was only pretending to be medicine. Aim your ire appropriately.



No, it's not. It's complaining about medicine that the National Institute of Health and other authority figures told you to take, that turned out to a waste of your time and mildly harmful.


So which national agency told you to pretend to recycle?


If they all say to recycle but don't provide the information or means to do it right, it's all pretend.


Seems to be a choice made on a state by state basis to even try:

https://www.ball.com/getmedia/ac92bef4-4784-4d96-8972-dd6e12...

But sure, I support the feds forcing the states to recycle properly, just as I support them being forced to offer decent healthcare.

The ones that opt out for sometimes inscrutable reasons doesn't mean the whole thing is a magic trick. It just means they are poorly run states with developing nation level provision of basic civic services.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: