Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If that was that easy why did the 3rd party apps shutdown rather then raise prices to cover the API fees?

Reddit's model was kind of novel in that they did it in directly by expecting the 3rd party apps to collect the payment from their users but they did essentially just ask people to pay for 3rd party app access.

I cant recall any instance where a social media company successfully extracted actual cash directly from their users that ended well.

if you look at what reddit was asking it kind of evened out to less then $5,- a month pr user which seems to have been so much more then what the 3rd party apps was able/willing to charge that they had to fold.




If you go look at their explanations, the 3rd party apps shut down because there was no transition plan for them to increase the price of only future payments (so, they would need to have billed people more months ago), and the prices were too high for the authors to absorb the loss.

So the authors did the only thing they could, that is returning all of recently billed money and closing their apps down.


Reddit jumped the change on the app developers -- it's easy to get the $5/mo by next year, not by tomorrow


> If that was that easy why did the 3rd party apps shutdown rather then raise prices to cover the API fees?

Because they're making the apps have to pay this fee with absolutely 0 notice.

They're putting the burden onto the apps. The solution here was to put the burden on Reddit (Where it would've made sense)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: