Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"When a man is sober he is ashamed of what seems all right when he is drunk. In these words we have the essential underlying cause prompting men to resort to stupefiers. People resort to them either to escape feeling ashamed after having done something contrary to their consciences, or to bring themselves beforehand into a state in which they can commit actions contrary to conscience, but to which their animal nature prompts them.

A man when sober is ashamed to go after a prostitute, ashamed to steal, ashamed to kill. A drunken man is ashamed of none of these things, and therefore if a man wishes to do something his conscience condemns he stupefies himself."

- Tolstoy (from the article)



This is the core of the issue. The thing is that in modern western societies shame is placed upon many activities that are normal and necessary for a human to enjoy a good life. It is shameful in many places for a person to sing, dance, and to express their true emotions. So we intoxicate ourselves, in order to escape from the overly rigid social conditioning we have all internalised.


    modern western societies shame is placed upon many activities that are normal and necessary for a human to enjoy a good life
Where are my Italians at? They don't do this. Probably Spaniards and Greeks also, but I have met far fewer.


And indeed, Mediterranean cultures tend to favour moderate (if steady) consumption of alcohol, rather than binge drinking.


Yes agreed. It seems to me that the more rigid the culture (Britain, Scandinavia, Japan etc) the more they binge drink.


Seems to only be focusing on mean drunks. I've never had the desire to do any of those things, drunk or sober, and I'm drunk almost every night.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: