Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Does something violate the rule if it’s allowed based on common sense? I don’t think so.


Depends on the definition of "common sense".

I've heard it said that common sense is just what naive people assume is obvious.

I'm not sure about that but I do know that people often disagree on what is and isn't common sense.

I guess this is why English Common Law works. We use precedence to argue about how the words of the law should be interpreted and at least try to flush out ambiguity.


Obviously, it does. The rule says "No vehicles in the park" and tells you specifically not to moralize , justify, or apply local laws.


It does not tell me not to moralize. It just tells me to not take any other rules into account that might exist, i.e. to not construct a legalistic argument.

But I don’t need to to allow ambulances. I think this is the core of what many engineers fundamentally don’t get about rules and laws in society?

The framing of the rules clearly places this rule firmly in the real world, in a real park.


Lots of people are in jail or fired after following that logic.


And some people who didn’t follow that logic allowed millions of people to be killed.

This all ain’t easy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: