> Coinbase' story seems to be that they asked how to apply to become a licensed pharmacist, but never got an answer. While the SEC suggests they never tried
They got an answer they didn't like: they'd have to change how they did business. (Also, what they list. The SEC issued The DAO Report in 2017.) We enacted the '34 Exchange Act in part to segregate the broker, exchange and custodial functions of securities trading. Coinbase was asking how to become a licensed pharmacist without having to check prescriptions.
> gets confusing when the crime is phrased as unregistered heroin sales
Try "opiate." Coinbase thought they found something new, and asked if it was okay. They didn't think they got a clear answer and proceeded. Now they're crying foul at the lack of prior guidance, or that someone else does have a license. The author's point is that these arguments don't make sense. There may be other arguments that do, but these aren't among them.
They got an answer they didn't like: they'd have to change how they did business. (Also, what they list. The SEC issued The DAO Report in 2017.) We enacted the '34 Exchange Act in part to segregate the broker, exchange and custodial functions of securities trading. Coinbase was asking how to become a licensed pharmacist without having to check prescriptions.
> gets confusing when the crime is phrased as unregistered heroin sales
Try "opiate." Coinbase thought they found something new, and asked if it was okay. They didn't think they got a clear answer and proceeded. Now they're crying foul at the lack of prior guidance, or that someone else does have a license. The author's point is that these arguments don't make sense. There may be other arguments that do, but these aren't among them.