Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

AI philosophy is its own academic discipline. Has been since around the 1970s. A lot of early academic experiments involving AI, e.g. ELIZA, most ALife research, Prolog-based expert systems, etc., can be best categorized (retroacively) as research into AI philosophy. No novel Computer Science principles were being explored; rather, what was being explored was the impact that certain novel applications of existing CS principles would have upon the world.

AI philosophy wasn't a very popular / widely-researched field, though, until recently, when AI ethics (ethics is considered part of philosophy) — and a specific subfield of that called "alignment research" — became something that a good number of philosophers became very concerned with.

Now there are many AI philosophers, employed not just in academia, but also in think-tank-like arms of AI technology companies like OpenAI (mostly because the AI tech companies know they're perceived as being irresponsible with how quickly they're iterating toward more-powerful AI, and so use employing AI philosophers as something like carbon credits to offset that perception.)

There is a lot of very good work done in AI philosophy; with many of the insights from alignment research specifically, being incorporated into the work that the AI tech companies are doing.

But none of this really "surfaces" in articles about AI that you might see floating about, because alignment research is really high-context — it's not really something you can write a fluff piece about; it's all stuff that requires knowledge of both philosophical (e.g. linguistics, decision theory) and computer science concepts to understand. Instead, all the normal articles about AI philosophy, are written by people doing amateur AI philosophy — usually resulting in them badly retreading the same ground that was already thoroughly explored in the 1970s.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: