Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yeah these intelligence tests are not very good.

I would argue some programmers do in fact invent something new. Not all of them, but some. Perhaps 10%.

Second the point is not whether everyone is by profession an inventor but whether most people can be inventors. And to a degree they can be. I think you underestimate that by a large margin.

You can lock people in a room and give them a problem to solve and they will invent a lot if they have the time to do it. GPT will invent nothing right now. It‘s not there yet.



>Yeah these intelligence tests are not very good.

Lol Okay

>And to a degree they can be. I think you underestimate that by a large margin.

Do i? Because i'm not the one making unverifiable claims here.

>You can lock people in a room and give them a problem to solve and they will invent a lot if they have the time to do it.

If you say so


> Not all of them, but some. Perhaps 10%.

Just listen to what you're saying:

- GPT isn't at human level because GPT isn't able to invent something new

- Not all programmers invent something new, but some. Perhaps 10%

I'm pretty sure this implies literally that 90% programmers aren't human level.

The lengths to which people are willing to go to dismiss GPT's abilities is mind boggling to me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: