Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


No; these are central bank currency swaps designed to improve dollar liquidity overseas. This has essentially nothing to do with QE or anything like that.


If the assets that are swapped were in fact worth what the swap line values them at, there would be no need for a swap line since the assets could be lent out in the open market. While you’re technically correct that it’s not QE, since the fed reserve is not directly purchasing assets, it has a similar effect on international markets. Foreign central banks purchase or lend USD to their local banks for assets which can’t be used as good collateral (meaning counterparties don’t believe the market has enough liquidity and/or the assets are valued under par) then these central banks, if they run low on USD, swap their own currency for USD through the swap lines.

The net result is USD flows out of the Federal Reserve and into foreign bank reserves, while illiquid and/or under par assets flow into foreign central banks while foreign currency flows into the federal reserve.

So it’s not really correct to say it isn’t like QE at all since in both types of stimulus new USD is issued by the federal reserve in exchange for assets. The difference is in the terms, counterparties, and types of assets.


>So it’s not really correct to say it isn’t like QE at all since in both types of stimulus new USD is issued by the federal reserve in exchange for assets.

Uhhh, OK, by that definition the Fed discount window is "a bit like QE" too.

>The difference is in the terms, counterparties, and types of assets.

This is ... not a subtle difference? QE is outright purchase, vs a relative short-term swap structure; domestic commercial banks, vs. foreign central banks; bonds and MBS vs. currency.


Great clarification, thanks!


They might call it something else but the effect is the same as QE. The FED’s balance sheet has expanded by $300 billion in the past few days [0] That is equivalent to the past 4 months of quantitative tightening.

This money is to be used to backstop insolvent banks and like all Fed created money it was created out of thin air. Make no mistake this will lead to even more inflation. [0]

[0] https://mobile.twitter.com/charliebilello/status/16364798793...

Edit: added context to the size of the QE that the Fed claims isn’t really QE.


That's not what QE is and it does not have the same effect as QE.


It’s a sudden expansion of the Fed’s balance sheet. What else would you call it?


A loan to provide liquidity. QE is the systematic increasing of bond values. These loans will have no effect on bond value and therefore interest rates because they have high interest rates and need to be paid back quickly. They just give debtors enough time to sell a few assets and wait for the situation to calm down.


See my edited comment above. The effect is to erase the past 4 months of quantitative tightening in a single week. We can agree not to call it QE but the effect is nonetheless inflationary as with all cases when the Fed creates money out of thin air, thereby diluting the purchasing power of all dollar holders.


No this is making sure distribution is in place for when the printer goes brrrr…

basically they are phoning the clubs and making sure bottles, Apple bottom jeans and the boots with the furs are there so when it’s time to make it rain the club is prepped and the money can be spent.


Laughed at that second part.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: