Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>There is no reason that novel pathways of "thought" (or whatever makes one comfortable) aren't emergent in a model under optimization & regularization.

Please substantiate this assertion. People always just state it as a fact without producing an argument for it.




You're asking me to substantiate a negative - ie. identify any possible reason someone might provide that novel behavior might not be emergent out of a model under optimization and then disprove it, but ahead of time. This is a challenging task.

Our minds are emergent out of the interaction of billions of neurons in our brain. Each is individually pretty dumb, just taking in voltage and outputting voltage (to somewhat oversimplify). Out of that simple interaction & under the pressures of evolutionary optimization, we have reached a more emergent whole.

Linear transformations stacked with non-linearities can similarly create an individually dumb input and output that under the pressure of optimization lead to a more emergent whole. If there is a reason why this has to be tied to voltage regulating neuron substrate, I have yet to see a compelling one.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: