Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Police work = killing people?



Sometimes, yes. In any interaction with police, there is a certain probability of the police killing someone. The killing may be justified (defense of self or community), or occasionally it might not be. But more criminals -> more interactions with police -> more opportunities for an interaction to become deadly.


Well I guess first do you have any sources for the more crime per capita claim?

Secondly, other countries seem to manage to do police work without killing a ridiculous number of citizens, so that's definitely kinda weird


https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/homicide-rate

(Homicide is generally the most accurately tallied crime, so best for such comparisons)

In general, countries with fewer killers and thugs per capita can afford a softer police touch. Maybe one day we in the US will figure out how to reduce or reform our population of unsavory individuals, but until then law enforcement have to deal with them as best they can.


I don't agree that homicide is the best for comparison, the original claim was about crime in general


I should have been more specific, said "violent crime".

For example Germany has no speed limits on highways, so I suppose they must have very few speeding tickets—but that's not very informative




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: