Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"Apple have also disabled downloads of apps and podcasts over 20 MB on the behest of a single carrier with a poor network (AT&T), applying the restriction to all phones, worldwide"

That's horrible.. is it true? Can anyone confirm this?




Yeah, you have to use Wifi to download apps over 20 MB. The podcast restriction only applies to the iTunes app, you can use third-party apps to download larger ones (except in the early days of the App Store, when third party podcast apps were forbidden)

Actually IIRC the whole iTunes music store is also disabled when you're on 3G and not Wifi. (edit: double-checked, yeah it's disabled for me http://db.tt/YT0w0rNQ )


Downloading apps/videos over 20MB on 3G isn't allowed, but you can browse the iTunes music store an buy songs (unless they're over 20MB, which is rare).

It seems to me like a sanity check. If a user accidentally downloaded a few 100MB files, they could easily get over their data cap. This restriction is not device wide, just on the iTunes App/Music store.


> Actually IIRC the whole iTunes music store is also disabled when you're on 3G and not Wifi.

you didn't recall correctly (at least not for my carrier).


I guess that's another thing Apple randomly disable or enable depending on the carrier http://db.tt/YT0w0rNQ


Yes, I just tried to download a 34MB game over 3G and this was the result

http://cl.ly/3W3M1g2q1J0B3T2K143d


You got to be kidding me! :O Really you can't download anything over 20mb! I can run a torrent and download anything i like on my android!


You can run a torrent client if you want, but some of the Android Market apps are flagged as Wi-Fi download only - the switch may be carrier specific, but see https://market.android.com/details?id=com.escapistgames.star... - this app will only download over Wi-Fi on my Nexus S (ICS, AT&T)


Yeah, and if everybody did that the network would melt in 2 hours, and you would be bitching about how slow it is...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: