Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

aeropress is just a low tech device built to sell filters. A regular french press doesn't need to buy disposable filters so is better.


Yeah, I'm sure Aeropress is making bank selling you $15 worth of filters once or twice a year[0]. Or you could spend that same $15 on Aeropress' stainless mesh filter[1], and they'll never see another dime from you again.

Downside to metal mesh filter: it doesn't pull out all of the oily residue that a paper filter would. It doesn't bother us, but you might be more picky.

[0] https://aeropress.com/products/micro-filters

[1] https://aeropress.com/products/aeropress-stainless-steel-reu...


I used a metal filter with my Aeropress for six years. It's fine. The paper filters are an option, not a requirement.


Yeah me too. I literally haven't even used the filters that came with the aeropress when I got it and I use mine every day.


I rinse and re-use the aeropress filters. If I'm somewhat careful handling them I get 10 uses or more per filter.


Maybe! But the filters are currently under €0.02 per unit on Amazon in a pack of 700 and it makes incredible coffee when paired with pretty much any (non spinny-blade) grinder, and pretty decent coffee when paired with preground. And the inventor says he washes the filters off and uses them two or three times each.


Aeropress and French Press make fundamentally different coffees. The paper filter in the Aeropress changes the taste and "feel" of the coffee in ways that many people prefer. Additionally, the pressure created during the "pressing" process changes the extraction a bit (nowhere near as much as espresso type pressures, but more than nothing).


The main issue with French press is that it's unfiltered and filtered coffee is considered healthier.


$4.99 for enough filters from Target to last me a year (350). Quite the money making scheme they have!


Except you can't produce a clean cup of coffee with a french press.


True, a french press tends to leave sediment at the bottom of your mug. Easily solved by leaving the last tiny sip behind.


What do you mean by clean in this context?


Filters remove sediment and oils, which gives the coffee a 'clean' mouth feel. A little hard to describe, but easy to observe if you make a french press and a v60/aeropress using the same beans and grind and compare.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: