Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> MBAs making supply chains inherently fragile and over who valued BS things like JIT are just reflecting what is most rewarded in the corpo culture:

Also reflected in what is most rewarded by consumers: lower prices.

No business was ever going to thrive selling US manufactured goods at a significant price premium compared to non US manufactured goods.




I dunno I'm currently trying to boycott Chinese made goods, regardless the cost. I'm in the position to be able to do that but so are many others.

It's like they're targeting the lowest common denominator.

It's a self fulfilling prophecy right? If the manufacturing was internal to the US say, theres more jobs hence better economy hence people are able too afford those locally prepared goods.

That probably requires a united front against outsourcing though. It's almost as if globalism breeds poverty, and is just a way for megacorps to milk us of our cash. Totally removed from any kind of social responsibility.

They sure love to change their logos to a rainbow and call that social responsibility though. Like Nike shipping you a keychain of all the micro plastics produced during the manufacturing of those shoes you just bought as if making you deal with their waste is environmental responsibility.


>It's almost as if globalism breeds poverty, and is just a way for megacorps to milk us of our cash.

Or it is arbitraging labor prices across different markets and lifting up others. Or it is also arbitraging environmental regulations and taking advantage of more corrupt/inept societies. Or it is also arbitraging better efficiencies in a more appropriately regulated economy, rather than an under or over regulated economy.


> trying to boycott Chinese made goods, regardless the cost. I'm in the position to be able to do that

Really? Did you post your comment by carrier pigeon?


I think the "wherever possible" is implied. Where does this kind of cheap-shot snark end? Shall we next post the We Should Improve Society Somewhat comic?

...besides, maybe they're posting from one of those Raspberry Pi Model Bs that were fabbed in the UK.


> maybe they're posting from one of those Raspberry Pi Model Bs that were fabbed in the UK.

That is connected to a router made in China. And the keyboard and display, where were they made? My point is that it is pretty much unachievable and your "wherever possible" is just a get out of jail free card. Also it isn't a particularly laudable aim if we scale it up to the whole of society. We need the various countries in the world to be interdependent, we need China to need to sell to us.


I just bought an oven made in Turkey. I bought various 4WD mods manufactured in Australia. Keyboard was made by me using parts from USA and Germany. Another keyboard made in Taiwan.

China (aka East Taiwan) makes cheap shit. If you have money you can afford the better manufactured stuff from non tofu-dreg countries.

We need to divulge from China a much as possible and many companies are. It is not ethical to do business with a country that has concentration camps. Hopefully one day the ROC will reclaim power over China and clean all that up.


Hoss, ask yer mechanic if his wrenches are Snap On or Harbor Freight.


>a significant price premium

Obviously paying the premium for Snap-On over harbor freight is worth it, for some people. Harbor Freight still makes the most sense for a huge portion of the market, reducing the market for US made tools.

Whatever the result, it will be visible in what succeeds in the market over the long term.


Yes, and Snap On is nonetheless thriving, selling US-manufactured goods at a significant price premium compared to cheap imports.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: