It left off some necessary vital signs from the scenario, then in the answer concluded that the patient had severe pneumonia and should be treated with a specific antibiotic.

Based on the prompt, the pneumonia probably wasn’t severe, antibiotics weren’t warranted, and even if they were, the antibiotic specified was completely wrong.

It looked fine to me—completely plausible. It took an expert to spot the flaws.

She also asked it to explain the work up for a febrile neonate. The answer again sounded plausible to me. But she said it sounded like a clueless med student trying to BS their way through an answer.