Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think pretending AirDrop is the only way people can coordinate is weird.



Yes, until every spark of freedom has been irreversibly extinguished, we are blameless for helping in that process.


What alternatives check off the following boxes?

* Can't be blocked or monitored by state-controlled Internet

* Is widely installed throughout the population already

* Existence of which is not evidence of anti-government organizing.

That's what made AirDrop sharing so powerful for protestors. They all already had it, having it is not suspicious, and using it doesn't rely on government internet filters allowing it.


Protests have been around for far longer than AirDrop has existed. It seems AirDrop was being used to share posters and slogans and perhaps some basic information, not as some kind of instant messaging app. If Chinese iPhone users are anything like American iPhone users, I'd guess that most wouldn't want to receive a ton of iPhone notifications for unsolicited content.


Paper?


I don't think anyone's claimed that was the case.

Apple isn't removing the only way to coordinate, but they are removing a mechanism which has reportedly been used by Chinese dissidents.


they aren't removing, they are limiting to 10mins.


Always-on is qualitatively different from "only on for 10 minutes".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: