Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

At the same time, storage of value bitcoiners - the majority that titanically dwarfs medium-of-exchange/currency bitcoiners - have been trying to get the average layman to put money into the system as much as possible. More bag holders at any cost.

And it turned out that that cost was something that would give the illusion of security, and hide away the technical minutiae that would prevent the system from sucking in those non-technical users.

The bitcoin and other crypto communities don't get to have it both ways. You can't pull in average folks with these mechanisms, to increase the value of your holdings, while simultaneously admonishing them for using and trusting the systems set up to bring them into the fold.




That doesn't make a whole lot of sense. For starters you make assumptions about the motivations of all 'Bitcoiners,' even extending your cynical projection to the ones most vocal about using Bitcoin safely.

But let's take the cynical viewpoint. If I, as a hypothetical Bitcoin holder, want the dollar value of my Bitcoin to go and stay up, then the last outcome I desire is for massive volumes of Bitcoin to end up centralized into a few pockets where they will be gambled on and sold when those bets fail. The most cynical Bitcoin holder has it in their interest for all retail holders to custody their own supply.

Considering the educated base of Bitcoiners have been screaming and citing examples of what happened with FTX since the protocol's inception, "Not your keys, not your coins," it's rather dubious to try and blame them. The reason people get into the space and trust their coins to some third party is that those people are chasing the end of a market cycle and never even come across or seek out the wisdom of the people that were they in the beginning.

'Bitcoiners' at large, judging by the on chain metrics for holders through negative price action, would much rather the volatile market cycles played out as a smoothed average with each new user coming in educated rather than speculators rushing in at the end by any means necessary.


thank you




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: