Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I am reasonably certain that a country well known for sending in the troops to crush rebellion would count as a dictatorship.



> reasonably certain that a country well known for sending in the troops to crush rebellion would count as a dictatorship

Authoritarian. China has been authoritarian for a long time. It only recently became a dictatorship, which is an inherently unstable form of government.


Yes, I agree. But the distinction isn't too useful. Most dictatorships are also authoritarian regimes.


Ok so you're going to have to resist all-caps replying "WHATABOUTISM!" but you realise by that definition both the USA and the UK could be "dictatorship" for sending in troops to crush both rebellion (the UK did in Northern Ireland) and protests (like USA did in Kent State)?

I said in another comment that I don’t wanna get into a debate on the subtleties of what is/isn’t a dictatorship, but THIS is an odd place to draw the line.


We're not arguing about the US or the UK here. Mainland China is the topic.


Well originally I was talking about why even though CCP is the single dominant party in China they still want some sort of exit from their Zero Covid policy that doesn't lose them face. Then you made an argument that they're a dictatorship on the grounds that they've turned their troops loose on their own people. Which is a surprising and extraordinary definition, because it also applies to the US and the UK - countries generally not thought of as "dictatorships".


Cool, have fun with that strawman




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: