Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

God forbid the US become a civilized nation and offer a real competitive national healthcare options. I live in one of the more expensive European nations when it comes to healthcare. €100~/mo with a €400~ deductible per year. Worst case scenario, I spend €1600/yr on healthcare.


How much do you pay when you factor in the taxes you also pay into the system?

If one gym had a yearly fee of $40 and then cost $1 every time you went, and another gym had a $8 yearly fee and cost $15 everytime you went, it wouldn't make sense to compare them merely on the per-visit costs.

Just to short circuit, I'm not trying to defend the American healthcare system. American healthcare is horrible on average compared to the average of other rich nations.

Also, a final note, but even if you have cheap out of pocket expenses, you aren't getting good value for your money if you don't visit a doctor for almost a decade. (Yes, I did e-stalk you for 60s to try to see what country to figure out average tax burden for healthvare, and ran across that fact on your intermittent fasting post)


In general, the US pays more, and has less effective healthcare than countries with universal/single-payer systems[1][2][3].

There's plenty of reasons for that.

[1] https://grattan.edu.au/news/more-expensive-but-less-effectiv...

[2] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/universal-health-...

[3] https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2...


I agree, but that doesn't mean OPs overall burden is capped at 1600 eur/year


These studies are using total spend - inclusive of taxation and direct payments.


In Canada my income tax rate is about on par with what I would pay in the states. If I lived in California my taxes would be higher.

Our sales taxes are a little higher than a lot of the states, though.

I’ll take that over the amount of money and time the US healthcare system siphoned off of me when I was healthy.


Sorry, coming back to this late, but in the hope that you see it, I haven't visited the doctor _because_ it was expensive. Sure, I'm also young and it probably wasn't really necessary, but there were definitely a couple of instances I can remember from the last decade that I didn't go to the doctor until I thought I had no other choice.

I'm willing to pay a little more in the long term to have the peace of mind that I can go to the doctor for something less than an emergency and not face financial hardship. In the US, one doctors visit can easily cost more than 10 years of bills in a European nation, and it doesn't even have to be serious! A broken leg isn't life threatening, but it could break you financially if you aren't ready and able to shell out your high deductible.


Is that one of those "civilised" countries that denies parents the right to take their child out of country to get medical help, even when there's no cost to said "civilised" country?


I think that you are watching Fox News a bit too much.


Yep. If your employer isn't subsidizing it for you, €1600/month (not a year) for a good employee+family plan would be a bargain in the US. And the deductible would still be thousands, not hundreds.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: