Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>https://www.computerworld.com/article/3292619/the-brave-brow...

What are you talking about. They are stealing from content creators / whom ever took the time to create the website to begin with and taking their money. They are literally leeches.

I don't care about the ad business and believe there are better ways to do this, but this is scummy stuff.

Use an ad blocker or whatever you want but this is another company profiting from it.




What's that link supposed to show? The quote at the top is about a theoretical version of the ads that I'm pretty sure never happened.

The ads go in the browser if you decide to turn them on. You can also turn off the ad blocker and have both, if you so desire.

I'm pretty sure having new tab ads and push notification ads does not leech off websites.

Ad blocking by itself is arguably leeching, but that's clearly not your argument if you suggest using other ad blockers.


>Ad blocking by itself is arguably leeching

Yes but we are not profiting from stealing ad revenue from content creators.

>I'm pretty sure having new tab ads and push notification ads does not leech off websites.

You wouldn't be using a browser to access content, and give them a reason to show you ads.


By that metric is a paid browser with ad blocking a leech? I don't think such a thing would be bad at all.


The article is wrong on multiple counts.

Brave's ad blocking and advertising are separate things - the adblocker is basically pretty much like uBO, but written in Rust and integrated as part of the browser.

Brave Rewards is a separate module that lets users watch ads that get delivered as toaster popups. Brave uses a part of the revenue to buy BAT from the open market and gives it to users who viewed the toaster popups. The company also operates a tipping service that lets users give those crypto tokens to content creators they like. (Since Brave buys the tokens, the tokens will have a buyer who pays with real money from the real, normal advertising business).

Second, the browser did actually start being built on top of Gecko - as far as I know they had an Electron-like solution just with Gecko, and used that for the first versions of the browser. Later they transitioned to being a Chromium soft fork.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: