Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

People want their browser to take away their choices? You don't need to switch browsers for that, I'm sure there are extensions on FF or Chrome that do the same thing.



Is this a serious question? At the beginning of the web era, popup ad windows were a horrible scourge. That problem was solved, and there was peace for many years. Now the websites themselves produce the popups. Nobody likes popup distractions. Cookie banners are just one example.


I don't like popups either. Every modern web browser already blocks them. This is just about cookie banners. They may be annoying but they let me withdraw consent to cookies.


Every modern browser does not already block them. Cookie banners are popups. Email signup prompts are popups. Requests to allow notifications are popups. Etc.


I was talking about popup windows.

You can block websites from asking for notification permissions.

Cookie banners and email signup prompts are part of the page. I don't consider them popups.


You can consider whatever you like, they are still "things that pop up" that most people simply don't want.


There are, I use one that does this for FF. Fewer choices maybe, but I don’t want to be inundated with these kinds of popups on every site.

If the site can function with fewer cookies it should simply do so by default.


So instead we just block cookie banners and let them assume consent by default?


I mean you can do as you want, but I find the extra clutter and visual noise of these banners infuriating.

Block them or don’t block them, it should be up to the user.


Yes choosing a browser to take away my choice is also a choice. Not one I would make, but to each their own, I guess.


Yes. Block the banners; let them assume what they like; and discard cookies automatically.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: