Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Adding or removing shards can get complicated and it is better to handle this at your application layer.

For instance, you could keep track of the configuration history - when adding a shard, you create a new version. And when trying to fetch, you could try the latest version of your configuration (which says, for example, that it's on server 3) and if not found you could try the previous version (which says that it's on server 1). You can also add the possibility of removing a shard, however this requires that for every write you'll have to do a secondary write to another server, for redundancy.

In the background you could have a healer that whenever a new version gets pushed, it would go through all entries and move them accordingly. And at the end it would declare such a version to be "healed".

However, what I described above works in case you want to introduce a new server in production immediately. Like say, in the case of something like Twitter, you want to write to the new shard right away and the most important messages are the most recent ones. But you may also want to create a configuration such that a new server isn't hit by the front-end until the healing script hasn't finished migrating.

The thing is, a layer like this gets to be very optimized for your needs and there's no one size fits all.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: