Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Chesterton’s fence fail.


>Chesterton’s fence fail.

Excellent point.

The legislature ripped quite a bit of privacy and freedom from the banking system post 9/11 on an almost blind rampage, without doing much stopping and asking why things were they were. I admit it was the ultimate Chesterton's fence fail on the government's part and likely a big reason why a new fence seems to have been built with crypto.

Honestly even bitcoin the white paper seems to have had more thought poured into it than the Patriot Act, which kicked off much of the KYC reforms in the US. In reality I think many of the adopters of cryptocurrency realized exactly the dystopia that the banking system was going down and very deliberately tried to take some of the failures of government into account.


People just don't want to pay their taxes,buy drugs/weapons/illegal porn or launder cash. Couching it in high minded ideals isn't fooling anyone.


Clearly anyone not happy with (or seeking alternatives to) the post 9/11 banking surveillance apparatus must be cast down as a nefarious character who isn't fooling anyone.


The libertarian fallacy: the solution to bad regulation is no regulation whatsoever.


The freen fallacy: anything between 'Patriot Act era KYC' and 'the <freen> solution' is libertarian nonsense.


Look: current financial regulations in the US and Europe mean we’ve been leapfrogged by Africa: M-Pesa etc.

Don’t disagree, but throwing the baby out with the bath water and going full raw dog lets speed run the entire history of financial fraud is not a good idea.


Speak for yourself. I've been able to send money to my friends' phone numbers for years.

America hasn't even discovered different colours for banknotes yet. It's parochialism, not regulation, holding you back.

Apart from that, nicely put.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: