Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm a free speech advocate but 100% agree with you.

Our legislators needs to make laws against targeted, anonymous, non-journalistic doxxing. It needs to include clauses that escalate the severity when revenge porn or racial, sexual, or other discrimination is being incited. If this bullying results in suicide, that should also increase the severity of the crime.

Until these laws exist, prosecutors need to use this angle and try these cases anyway.




Non-journalistic doxxing? What makes doxxing someone journalistic and why is it okay when a journalist does it?


Documenting any of:

- leader of a mafia

- any government leader

- billionaires in general

- anyone in a position of power

Investigating their crimes and doxxing them is very different from "lmao look at this piece of shit loser, let's bully it to death".


If someone is the leader of a mafia and it is known without a doubt and you know their location you should call the police not put it in the news. What does "government leader" means? what does "anyone in a position of power" actually means? Especially in the era of twitter and immense followings from people that are just regulars and not some ultra-rich celebrities.

Man it really didn't take long for people to forget things like the CNN reddit kid dox or even more recent the twitter account from tiktok dox by journalists active still today.

[0]https://edition.cnn.com/2017/07/04/politics/kfile-reddit-use...


>If someone is the leader of a mafia and it is known without a doubt and you know their location you should call the police not put it in the news.

Fair enough.

>What does "government leader" means?

>what does "anyone in a position of power" actually means?

I'm not a lawmaker, it's one of those "you know it when you see it" things.

>Man it really didn't take long for people to forget things like the CNN reddit kid dox or even more recent the twitter account from tiktok dox by journalists active still today.

That's exactly why I put the above caveat.


Journalists are the guardians of democracy.

Now be a good boy or else CNN might release your name and address: https://www.engadget.com/2017-07-05-cnn-will-expose-reddit-u...


Why would the US make any laws against doxxing? As of so far we've been nearly completely allergic to any laws for privacy. It's going to be very problematic in itself attempting to make a legal argument that disclosing an anonymous persons name is not protected under the first amendment.


Whoever still puts out a phone book is going to be in big trouble.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: